It's hard to vote for a game to be a 5/5, is it good for everyone? No. Does it have flaws? Yes, but not enough to remove a star from the rating. You could play this game for over a 100 hours and still find more things you didn't discover before, the storytelling and world-building is some of the best ever in gaming history. Beautiful views, character designs, layouts and music. You can approach this game as you wish, if you prefer using magic you can go that route. If you prefer using swords and armors you can as well, tank, light, whatever, the choice is yours, it will change difficulty levels at varying stages depending what you choose but overall it would be equally difficult whatever route you go, just at the different times.